No site can promise a relationship, and none publishes a reliable success rate, so be wary of any that claims one. What a site can do is attract people who want to commit and give you the tools to find them: full profiles, ways to show intentions, and a design that rewards conversation over volume.
How we chose: we looked for services with a real UK presence whose own pages describe a relationship focus, and compared how you find people, what is free, how contact starts and what checks are available, using each company's own pages (sources at the end). We did not test them with accounts and we do not give scores. Smooch is our own site; we include it because it meets the same criteria, and it is not ranked above the others.
