The big difference is who does the choosing. On Match you search, filter and decide who to contact. On eharmony the Compatibility Quiz does the first round for you and sends suggestions, which suits people who find browsing tiring or who want a narrower shortlist.
How we compared them: we used each company's own UK help and pricing pages, the US Federal Trade Commission and the UK Advertising Standards Authority, all listed at the end. We did not test either with accounts. Smooch is a dating site too; we mention it once, as our own, at the end.
