Plenty of Fish Alternatives: Sites and Apps Like Plenty of Fish

Updated · By Smooch Editorial Team · Editor: Bill Alena

Plenty of Fish (POF) is popular because free members can message anyone. If its busy inbox, ads or mixed intentions put you off, these alternatives work differently: some are quieter and search-based, some only let matches talk, and some are paid sites for relationships.
Two phones showing dating app profiles side by side

What Are the Best Alternatives to Plenty of Fish?

💡If you like POF's search tools, Match and Smooch let you search and browse full profiles. If you want fewer unwanted messages, Hinge and Bumble only let people talk after a match. For free messaging like POF, OkCupid and Facebook Dating are the closest.

How we chose: we included services with a real UK presence that work in a clearly different way from Plenty of Fish, and described each from its own help or feature pages and the reviews linked below. We run Smooch, which is in the list; weigh that accordingly.

AlternativeWhat is different from Plenty of FishWhat you get free
Smooch (our site)Search and browse profiles, no swipe feed; optional ID check with a badgeJoin and browse free; £19.99 a month (UK) to message
MatchSearch and browse full profiles; long-term focusProfile and a selection of members; subscription to message
HingePrompts and comments instead of plain swipes; aimed at relationshipsAbout 8 likes a day; message matches
BumbleEither person can send one opening message; 72 hours to replySwipe, match and message free
TinderThe biggest swipe app; quick, photo-led matchingSwipe, match and message; daily like limit
OkCupidAnswers to questions shape who you seeMessage after a mutual match; one intro message before matching
Facebook DatingNo paid tier; uses your Facebook accountFree after a match
eharmonyCompatibility quiz and suggested matchesBasic: quiz, profile, limited messaging
OurTimeOnly for people over 50; search and browseBrowse and search; messaging not listed as free

Why Do People Look for an Alternative to Plenty of Fish?

💡The usual reasons are too many unwanted or scam messages, a lot of ads on the free version, mixed intentions, and confusing tiers and tokens. The free messaging that makes POF popular is also what makes its inbox busy.

If messages from anyone are the problem, a match-only app such as Hinge or Bumble cuts the noise. If you liked searching profiles but want a quieter site, Match or Smooch work that way. Our Plenty of Fish review has more on POF itself.

What Is the Best Free Alternative to Plenty of Fish?

💡Facebook Dating has no paid tier, OkCupid lets you message after a mutual match, and Hinge and Bumble let you message matches free with limits. None is as open as POF, which is the point if you want fewer messages.

Our guide to dating sites with free messaging goes through what each one allows.

Is Smooch a Good Alternative to Plenty of Fish?

💡Smooch, our own site, has run since 2001. It is free to join, messaging needs one membership at £19.99 a month in the UK ($19.99 in the US), and you search and browse profiles rather than swipe.

Members can choose to verify their ID with a photo ID and selfie for an "ID verified" badge, photos are checked and moderators review reports. Membership is one monthly price, shown before you pay, and you can cancel online. See how Smooch works.

How Do You Choose Between Them?

💡Start with what you want to change about Plenty of Fish: the way you meet people, the cost, or who is on it. Then try one or two free versions for a week before paying for anything.

Check three things before you pay anywhere: the total for the whole plan, when it renews, and how to cancel. Our dating site prices guide shows how UK sites charge, and is Plenty of Fish free? explains what you can do on Plenty of Fish without paying.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Plenty of Fish?
For a quieter, search-based site try Match or Smooch. For match-only messaging try Hinge or Bumble. For free messaging, OkCupid and Facebook Dating are the closest.
Is there a free site like Plenty of Fish?
Facebook Dating has no paid tier, and OkCupid, Hinge and Bumble let you message matches free with limits. POF is unusual in letting free members message anyone.
Is Match better than Plenty of Fish?
Match suits people who want a long-term relationship and are happy to pay to message. POF suits people who want to message free and do not mind a busy inbox.
Who owns Plenty of Fish?
Plenty of Fish is owned by Match Group, which also owns Tinder, Hinge, Match and OurTime.

Sources

  1. Match Group: about (brands owned by Match Group)
  2. SwipeStats: dating apps with free messaging (updated September 2026)
  3. Ofcom: top online dating trends (UK usage of dating services)
  4. Apple: cancel a subscription (for app store subscriptions)

How we research and update guides: editorial policy. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.

Ready to Make Real Connections?

Free to join. Verify your ID to show an “ID verified” badge on your profile.

Create your free profile