Plenty of Fish vs Tinder: Which Is Better for You?

Updated · By Smooch Editorial Team · Editor: Bill Alena

Plenty of Fish and Tinder are two of the biggest free dating apps, both owned by Match Group. POF lets free members search and message anyone; Tinder only lets you message people you have matched with. Here is how they compare and which suits you.
Two phones showing dating app profiles side by side

Plenty of Fish or Tinder: Which Is Better?

💡Plenty of Fish suits people who want to search and message without matching first, and do not mind a busy inbox. Tinder suits people who want quick, photo-led matching where only mutual matches can talk.

Both are owned by Match Group and both are free to use. The big difference is who can message you: on POF anyone can, on Tinder only people you have matched with. That makes POF more open and Tinder quieter but more dependent on photos.

How Do Plenty of Fish and Tinder Compare?

💡The table sets Plenty of Fish and Tinder side by side on how you meet people, what is free, prices, verification and who uses each.

Plenty of FishTinder
How you meet peopleSearch, browse and message anyoneSwipe; message after a mutual match
Free messagingYes, without a matchYes, after a match
Free limitsAds; extras need upgrades or tokensDaily like limit; ads
Published pricesUS App Store: $29.99 for one month (Nov 2026)No, in the app only
VerificationOptionalFace Check for new members in many places, including the UK
OwnerMatch GroupMatch Group

Based on each service's own help pages and the reviews linked below, checked November 2026. Features change, so check before you pay.

Is Plenty of Fish or Tinder Cheaper?

💡Both are free to use for the basics. POF's US App Store page listed a one-month subscription at $29.99 in November 2026; Tinder does not publish its prices outside the app.

See is Plenty of Fish free? and is Tinder free? for what each free version includes.

Who Should Choose Plenty of Fish?

💡Choose Plenty of Fish if you want to search for people and message them without waiting for a match, and you are comfortable filtering a busy inbox.

Read our Plenty of Fish review for what to watch out for, including scam messages.

Who Should Choose Tinder?

💡Choose Tinder if you want the biggest pool of people, quick matching, and only to hear from people you have liked back.

Our Tinder review covers the paid tiers and Face Check.

Which Is Safer?

💡Tinder's Face Check for new members means more profiles have been checked against a live selfie. On POF, anyone can message you, so expect more unwanted and scam messages. On either, keep chats on the app until you have video called, and never send money.

Our guide to romance fraud explains the common patterns.

Is Smooch an Alternative to Plenty of Fish and Tinder?

💡Smooch, our own site, has run since 2001. It is free to join, messaging needs one membership at £19.99 a month in the UK ($19.99 in the US), and you search and browse profiles rather than swipe.

Members can choose to verify their ID with a photo ID and selfie for an "ID verified" badge, photos are checked and moderators review reports. Membership is one monthly price, shown before you pay, and you can cancel online. See how Smooch works.

Frequently asked questions

Is Plenty of Fish or Tinder better?
POF is better if you want to search and message without a match. Tinder is better if you want quick matching and only to hear from mutual matches.
Is Plenty of Fish more serious than Tinder?
Both have mixed intentions. POF lets you search by what you want; Tinder relies more on photos. Neither is designed only for serious relationships.
Are POF and Tinder owned by the same company?
Yes, both are owned by Match Group.
Which has more scams, POF or Tinder?
Because anyone can message anyone on POF, its members tend to get more unwanted and scam messages. Tinder only allows messages between matches.

Sources

  1. Apple App Store: POF Dating (US) (checked 20 November 2026)
  2. Tinder: subscription tiers (checked November 2026)
  3. Global Dating Insights: Tinder rolls out Face Check for new UK users (March 2026)

How we research and update guides: editorial policy. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.

Ready to Make Real Connections?

Free to join. Verify your ID to show an “ID verified” badge on your profile.

Create your free profile