St. Augustine Dating Sites: Free Dating, Singles and Date Ideas in St. Augustine

Updated · By Smooch Editorial Team · Editor: Bill Alena

This guide compares dating sites in St. Augustine with local census figures: the city has about 8,040 unmarried adults, 57.2% of everyone aged 18 and over, against 48.6% across Florida. Its median age is 49.9, and there are 69 unmarried men for every 100 unmarried women, well below Florida's 86.

What Is Dating Like in St. Augustine?

💡Dating in St. Augustine is romantic but small-scale. The city founded by the Spanish in 1565 has only about 15,400 residents and a median age of 49.9, so most people date across St. Johns County and as far as Jacksonville, with historic downtown and the beaches as the backdrop.

Few American cities make a first date as easy to plan. Coquina walls, narrow lanes and the Castillo de San Marcos give the old town its character, the Bridge of Lions leads to Anastasia Island and its beaches, and the city glows each winter with Nights of Lights. The catch is size: the city itself is small, and much of the area's population lives outside its limits in St. Johns County.

Flagler College, housed in Henry Flagler's former Hotel Ponce de Leon, brings students downtown, but with a median age of 49.9 the dating pool is mostly older. Jacksonville is about 40 miles north and Daytona Beach about an hour south. See also the Florida dating guide, dating in the USA and Daytona Beach.

Smooch has run since 2001 and is free to join; you browse profiles rather than swipe, and a paid membership is needed to message.

How Many Singles Live in St. Augustine?

💡St. Augustine has about 8,040 unmarried adults, 57.2% of residents aged 18 and over, against 48.6% across Florida. There are about 3,290 unmarried men and 4,760 unmarried women, or 69 men for every 100 women, well below the Florida figure of 86.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 5-year estimates (tables B01003, B01002 and B12002). Figures are survey estimates.
MeasureSt. AugustineFloridaUnited States
Population15,40022.42 million334.92 million
Median age49.942.638.9
Unmarried adults (18 and over)8,040 (57.2% of adults)8.77 million (48.6% of adults)125.74 million (48.1% of adults)
Unmarried men3,2904.06 million59.49 million
Unmarried women4,7604.72 million66.24 million
Unmarried men per 100 unmarried women698690
Never married (share of people 15 and over)38.1%31.7%34.4%
Unmarried means never married, divorced or widowed. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024, table B12002.
AgeUnmarried menUnmarried womenMen per 100 women
20 to 341,1301,30087
35 to 49730630116
50 to 6462078079
65 and over4701,30036

St. Augustine is older than Florida as a whole, with a median age of 49.9 against 42.6, and more of its adults are unmarried. Its balance is also markedly uneven: 69 unmarried men for every 100 unmarried women overall.

The gap is widest among older residents. At 65 and over there are about 1,300 unmarried women and 470 unmarried men, or 36 men per 100 women, because women live longer and men remarry more often. At 50 to 64 the figure is 79. Under 35 women also slightly outnumber men, at 87 per 100, while the 35 to 49 group is the exception, at 116, though the numbers there are small.

For women over 50, searching across St. Johns County, Palm Coast and Jacksonville makes a real difference. Our guides to dating over 60 and dating after bereavement may help.

These are survey estimates for the city of St. Augustine only, with wide margins of error for a place this size. They describe legal marital status, so they include people living with a partner and are not a count of people who are looking.

What Are the Best Dating Sites and Apps in St. Augustine?

💡St. Augustine is a small city of 15,400 with a median age of 49.9, so the best dating sites here let you search well beyond the city limits. Plenty of Fish and Smooch let you search by age across St. Johns County and Jacksonville, eharmony offers a free Basic profile, and Badoo lets you message free.

With only 8,040 unmarried adults inside the city, St. Augustine's own pool is small on any app, and much of the area's population lives outside its limits in St. Johns County. A wide search radius matters more here than which app you choose. The median age of 49.9 is well above Florida's 42.6, and women outnumber men in most age groups: 87 unmarried men per 100 women at 20 to 34, 79 at 50 to 64 and 36 over 65. The 35 to 49 group is the exception, at 116, though the numbers are small. For most people, especially women over 50, a site that searches by age and distance across Palm Coast and Jacksonville works best.

Dating sites and apps for singles in St. Augustine, free features checked November 2026 on each company's own pages
Site or appFree to join?Free messaging?Good for
Plenty of FishYesYes with matches, plus a few first messages a day to othersSearching St. Johns County and Jacksonville by age
eharmonyYes: free BasicLimited on Basic; unlimited is PremiumA free Basic profile before choosing Premium
Facebook DatingYes, with a Facebook accountYes, after a matchFree chats after a match, with no paid tier
BadooYesYesMessaging without paying
HingeYesAfter a match; about 8 likes a day freeFree chats with matches
BumbleYesAfter a match; either person can open, 72 hours to replyEither person can open after a match
SmoochYes: profile, search and browseNo: $19.99 a monthSearching by place and age rather than swiping

How we chose: we compared what each service lets you do free, from its own pages checked in November 2026, and looked at how well it suits a small city of 15,400 with a median age of 49.9. Smooch is our own site, listed last.

Are There Free Dating Sites in St. Augustine?

💡Yes. Every site in the table is free to join and browse in St. Augustine. Badoo lets you message without paying, Facebook Dating has no paid tier and Plenty of Fish allows a few first messages a day. In a city of 15,400, free browsing shows quickly how far you need to search.

Paid tiers mainly add reach: Tinder has a daily like limit and charges to see who liked you, Hinge gives about 8 likes a day free, and OkCupid lets you send one intro message before a match. eharmony keeps unlimited messaging for Premium, and Smooch needs a membership to message.

A practical tip for St. Augustine: set your distance to take in St. Johns County, Palm Coast and Jacksonville, about 40 miles north, and consider Daytona Beach, about an hour south. For women over 65, where there are 36 unmarried men per 100 women in the city, the wider setting makes the biggest difference. Our guides to free dating, the best free dating sites in the US and is Plenty of Fish free? explain each free version.

Where Do Singles Meet in St. Augustine?

💡Singles in St. Augustine meet at concerts and the farmers market at the St. Augustine Amphitheatre, during Nights of Lights, on St. George Street and around the Plaza, through Flagler College events, and on the beaches of Anastasia Island.

  • The Amp. The St. Augustine Amphitheatre on Anastasia Island hosts concerts and a community farmers market and night market.
  • Nights of Lights. Light-Up! Night and the weeks after it bring locals downtown.
  • Downtown. St. George Street and the Plaza de la Constitución are the heart of evenings out.
  • Volunteering. The St. Augustine Amphitheatre runs a volunteer programme.
  • Outdoors. Anastasia State Park, the beaches and the water draw walkers, paddlers and anglers.

For bigger cities, see Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa, St. Petersburg, Miami and Port St. Lucie. Our profile tips help you stand out.

Which St. Augustine Areas Are Best for a Date?

💡For a first date in St. Augustine, the historic downtown around St. George Street and the Plaza is the obvious choice. Lincolnville suits a quieter walk, Uptown suits a relaxed drink, and Anastasia Island suits the beach and the lighthouse.

AreaFeelBest forPlaces to start
Historic downtownNarrow lanes and Spanish colonial buildingsA first drink or dinnerSt. George Street, the Plaza, Castillo de San Marcos
LincolnvilleHistoric neighbourhood south of downtownA quiet walkIts streets and civil rights history
Uptown and San Marco AvenueOlder houses north of the gatesA relaxed drinkLocal bars and cafés
Anastasia IslandBeaches across the Bridge of LionsA daytime dateSt. Augustine Lighthouse, the Amp, Anastasia State Park
Vilano BeachQuieter beach to the northA sunset walkThe beach and the Intracoastal

What Are the Best Date Ideas in St. Augustine?

💡Good date ideas in St. Augustine include an evening during Nights of Lights, a walk across the Bridge of Lions, the Castillo de San Marcos, climbing the 1874 St. Augustine Lighthouse, a concert at the Amp, and the free ferry to Fort Matanzas.

BudgetIdeaWhy it works
FreeNights of Lights from late November to JanuaryMore than 3 million white lights across downtown
FreeA walk across the Bridge of Lions at sunsetViews back to the old city
FreeThe ferry to Fort MatanzasA short boat trip to a Spanish fort; it does not run on Tuesdays or Wednesdays
Low costCastillo de San MarcosThe oldest masonry fort in the continental United States
Mid-rangeClimbing the St. Augustine LighthousePanoramic views and a maritime museum
Mid-rangeA concert at the St. Augustine AmphitheatreOpen-air concerts on Anastasia Island
SpecialA day at Anastasia State ParkBeach, dunes and lagoon

On a rainy day, the Lightner Museum makes a good indoor date. More ideas are in our first date ideas guide.

How Does Smooch Work for Singles in St. Augustine?

💡Smooch is free to join in St. Augustine. You find people by searching and browsing profiles rather than swiping, and a paid membership ($19.99 a month in the US, shown before you pay) is needed to message. You can cancel online at any time.

Smooch has been running since 2001. You create a profile, say who you would like to meet and how far you are willing to travel, then search and browse members near you. There is one membership with no tiers, credits or add-ons. See how Smooch works and membership and prices.

Members can choose to verify their photo ID and show an ID verified badge, and every new photo is checked. It is optional, so look for the badge and read how verification works and how Smooch keeps you safe.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best dating site or app in St. Augustine?
Because St. Augustine is small, with 8,040 unmarried adults, the best site is one that lets you search by age and distance across St. Johns County and Jacksonville, such as Plenty of Fish or Smooch. Hinge and Bumble add free chats with matches.
Are there free dating sites in St. Augustine?
Yes. All the main dating sites are free to join and browse in St. Augustine. Badoo lets you message without paying and Facebook Dating has no paid tier, while Hinge and Bumble allow free messages after a match.
How many singles are in St. Augustine?
Census estimates put St. Augustine's unmarried adults at about 8,040, which is 57.2% of residents aged 18 and over.
Are there more single men or women in St. Augustine?
More women overall, with 69 unmarried men per 100 unmarried women. At 65 and over the figure falls to 36.
Where can I meet singles in St. Augustine without apps?
Try concerts and the farmers market at the St. Augustine Amphitheatre, Nights of Lights events, volunteering, and Anastasia State Park.
What is a good first date in St. Augustine?
A walk down St. George Street to the Castillo de San Marcos, then across the Bridge of Lions at sunset.
When is Nights of Lights in St. Augustine?
It usually runs nightly from late November to mid-January, with more than 3 million white lights across downtown, and it is free.
How much does Smooch cost in St. Augustine?
Smooch is free to join and create a profile. A paid membership, $19.99 a month in the US and shown before you pay, is needed to message, and you can cancel online at any time.

Sources

  1. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 5-year estimates, table B12002: Sex by marital status by age (St. Augustine city, Florida) (Unmarried men and women by age; checked November 2026)
  2. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 5-year estimates, tables B01003 (total population) and B01002 (median age) (St. Augustine city, Florida) (Population and median age; checked November 2026)
  3. National Park Service: Castillo de San Marcos National Monument (Oldest masonry fortification in the continental United States; checked November 2026)
  4. National Park Service: Fort Matanzas National Monument, Basic Information (Free ferry, no service on Tuesdays or Wednesdays; checked November 2026)
  5. Florida's Historic Coast: Nights of Lights (Free display of more than 3 million white lights from late November to January; checked November 2026)
  6. St. Augustine Lighthouse and Maritime Museum (1874 lighthouse, climbing and museum; checked November 2026)
  7. St. Augustine Amphitheatre (Concerts, farmers market and night market on Anastasia Island; checked November 2026)
  8. Flagler College: About (College housed in Henry Flagler's former Hotel Ponce de Leon; checked November 2026)
  9. Tinder: Subscription tiers (Free version has a daily like limit; paid tiers show who liked you; checked November 2026)
  10. Hinge Help Center: Likes (About 8 likes a day on the free version; checked November 2026)
  11. Bumble: Opening Moves (Either person can send one opening message after a match; the match expires after 72 hours without a reply; checked November 2026)
  12. eharmony (US): How much does eharmony cost? (Limited messaging on free Basic; unlimited messaging in Premium on 3, 6 and 12 month plans; checked November 2026)

How we research and update guides: editorial policy. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.

Ready to Make Real Connections?

Free to join. Verify your ID to show an “ID verified” badge on your profile.

Create your free profile